The archive13

Every edition. An expanding view of orthopaedic evidence.

The complete collectionBrowse published appraisals
13 papers · Systematic review
1.SportsSystematic reviewArthroscopy The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery

Double‐Row Repair Improves Outcomes for Large Rotator Cuff Tears but Offers No Advantage for Small‐to‐Medium Tears: A Systematic Review and Meta‐analysis of Randomised Controlled Trials

This helps surgeons decide when the extra time and cost of double-row fixation is justified: reserving it for larger tears while using the faster single-row technique for small-to-medium tears.

Rigour88/100
Clinical75/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Strong
2.ArthroplastySystematic reviewBone & Joint Open

Comparative efficacy of analgesic techniques in total hip arthroplasty

This challenges the assumption, embedded in current PROSPECT guidelines, that specific regional blocks meaningfully reduce pain after hip arthroplasty, and instead points clinicians toward opioid-sparing and discharge-related benefits rather than pain control itself.

Rigour60/100
Clinical80/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Sound
3.SpineSystematic reviewPLoS Medicine

Cost-effectiveness of recommended interventions for managing low back pain: A systematic review

Knowing that guideline-endorsed conservative care for non-specific low back pain is usually good value supports referring patients to exercise, psychological and self-management programmes rather than escalating to costlier invasive care.

Rigour64/100
Clinical48/100
Impact†51/100
Source band: Limited
4.ArthroplastySystematic reviewBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders

GLP-1 receptor agonists for osteoarthritis: what does the evidence show?

GLP-1 agonists are now widely prescribed for obesity, so students should know that they may ease knee osteoarthritis pain but have not been shown to prevent joint replacement.

Rigour59/100
Clinical64/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Limited
5.Shoulder & ElbowSystematic reviewShoulder & Elbow

Home-based versus outpatient rehabilitation after shoulder arthroplasty

Postoperative therapy after shoulder replacement is costly and burdensome for older patients, and these trials suggest a surgeon-directed home programme may yield similar 1-year outcomes after reverse shoulder arthroplasty.

Rigour40/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†67/100
Source band: Limited
6.ArthroplastySystematic reviewArthroscopy Sports Medicine and Rehabilitation

Both Knotless and Traditional Knot‐Tying Suture Anchors Result in Favourable Clinical Outcomes in the Treatment of Acetabular Labral Tears: A Systematic Review

Hip arthroscopists choosing between knotless and knot-tying anchors for labral repair can be reassured both options yield good outcomes, though the mHHS signal favouring knotless warrants cautious interpretation given major heterogeneity and no formal meta-analysis.

Rigour51/100
Clinical52/100
Impact†54/100
Source band: Limited
7.SportsSystematic reviewArthroscopy The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery

Quadriceps Tendon Autograft for Primary Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Has No Difference in Short‐Term Clinical Outcomes Between All‐Soft Tissue Versus Tendon–Bone Grafts: A Systematic Review

Quadriceps tendon autograft is increasingly used for ACL reconstruction, and choosing whether to take a patellar bone block is a common intraoperative decision with trade-offs between bone healing and patellar fracture risk.

Rigour50/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
8.SportsSystematic reviewSports Health A Multidisciplinary Approach

Rehabilitative and Conditioning Exercises That Selectively Activate Individual Lower Extremity Muscles: A Systematic Review

Gives clinicians and trainers an evidence-mapped catalog of exercises for targeted muscle activation in rehab and injury prevention, while exposing major gaps (e.g., piriformis, pectineus) that limit current individualized prescription.

Rigour58/100
Clinical44/100
Impact†48/100
Source band: Limited
9.GeneralSystematic reviewJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research

Clinical translation of artificial intelligence in musculoskeletal care: a systematic review of current applications, evidence gaps, and implementation readiness

Orthopaedic surgeons increasingly encounter AI-assisted imaging tools, and this review shows the evidence supporting their clinical use remains extremely thin despite hype.

Rigour43/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Limited
10.SpineSystematic reviewSports Medicine

Biomechanics of Rugby Tackle Techniques in Youth and Adult Players: A Systematic Review of Age-Specific Injury Risk and Performance Implications

These findings help clinicians and coaches understand which biomechanical tackle features drive concussion and cervical injury risk, informing age-appropriate coaching to reduce injury in a sport with very high concussion rates during tackling.

Rigour40/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†48/100
Source band: Limited
12.ArthroplastySystematic reviewArthroscopy The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery

Segmental and Circumferential Hip Labral Reconstructions Both Show Favourable Outcomes in Primary Hip Arthroscopy: A Systematic Review

Hip arthroscopists frequently must choose between segmental and circumferential labral reconstruction when a labrum is unsalvageable, and this review highlights that the choice currently rests on limited, non-comparative, low-level evidence rather than proven superiority of either technique.

Rigour38/100
Clinical46/100
Impact†48/100
Source band: Limited
13.ArthroplastySystematic reviewArthroscopy The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery

Isolated Hip Arthroscopy Provides Comparable Mid‐ to Long‐Term Outcomes in Borderline Hip Dysplasia and Normal Hips: A Systematic Review and Meta‐analysis

This informs surgeons and patients whether borderline dysplastic hips can be safely treated arthroscopically without incurring worse durability compared to normally covered hips, which is a common intraoperative decision point in young active patients with FAIS.

Rigour40/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†48/100
Source band: Weak
Scores are out of 100. † Impact reflects editorial priority.
Paper selection

A critical eye. An open method.