The archive154

Every edition. An expanding view of orthopaedic evidence.

The complete collectionBrowse published appraisals
1.GeneralRCTClinical Rehabilitation

Effects of short-term compression in people with knee osteoarthritis: A sham-controlled randomised trial

Compression bandaging and soft braces are commonly recommended or self-applied for knee osteoarthritis pain, and this trial suggests short courses of simple elastic compression have no clinically meaningful benefit over a sham wrap or no treatment, which should temper enthusiasm for this low-cost adjunct.

Rigour100/100
Clinical66/100
Impact†65/100
Source band: Strong
2.SportsSystematic reviewArthroscopy The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery

Double‐Row Repair Improves Outcomes for Large Rotator Cuff Tears but Offers No Advantage for Small‐to‐Medium Tears: A Systematic Review and Meta‐analysis of Randomised Controlled Trials

This helps surgeons decide when the extra time and cost of double-row fixation is justified: reserving it for larger tears while using the faster single-row technique for small-to-medium tears.

Rigour88/100
Clinical75/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Strong
3.SpineMulticentreJAMA Network Open

Glucagon-Like Peptide-1 Receptor Agonists and Fragility Fracture Risk in Type 2 Diabetes

Orthopaedic surgeons increasingly manage fragility fractures in an aging population on GLP-1 receptor agonists, and this large observational signal raises the question of whether these drugs affect bone health differently than assumed.

Rigour70/100
Clinical77/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Sound
4.ArthroplastySystematic reviewBone & Joint Open

Comparative efficacy of analgesic techniques in total hip arthroplasty

This challenges the assumption, embedded in current PROSPECT guidelines, that specific regional blocks meaningfully reduce pain after hip arthroplasty, and instead points clinicians toward opioid-sparing and discharge-related benefits rather than pain control itself.

Rigour60/100
Clinical80/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Sound
7.Foot & AnkleRCTBMJ

Efficacy and cost effectiveness of high volume injections with and without corticosteroid compared with sham for midportion Achilles tendinopathy (Inject trial): randomised controlled trial

High volume injections are increasingly offered for stubborn Achilles tendinopathy, and this sham-controlled trial suggests they add no lasting benefit to exercise, with steroid offering only brief relief and possible later harm.

Rigour100/100
Clinical59/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Sound
8.TraumaRCTJournal of Pediatric Orthopaedics

Casting Without Reduction Versus Reduction With or Without Fixation for Mildly Displaced Paediatric Distal Radius Metaphyseal Fractures: A Randomised Noninferiority Trial

Paediatric distal radius fractures are the most common childhood fracture, and knowing when remodelling makes reduction unnecessary can spare young children anaesthesia, pins, and their complications.

Rigour62/100
Clinical65/100
Impact†65/100
Source band: Sound
11.SportsRCTThe American Journal of Sports Medicine

A Single Intra-articular Injection of Autologous Stromal Vascular Fraction for Moderate-to-Severe Knee Osteoarthritis: Results of a Multicentre Randomised Placebo-Controlled Trial With 12-Month Follow-up

Cell-based injections for knee arthritis are widely marketed, so a sham-controlled trial showing a 12-month responder benefit (with a wide confidence interval and an unusual composite endpoint) is directly relevant to how you counsel patients asking about biologics.

Rigour86/100
Clinical62/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Sound
12.GeneralRCTArthritis & Rheumatology

Outcomes of Tapering Biologic and Targeted Synthetic DMARDs in Rheumatoid Arthritis: A Multicentre Randomised Non‐Inferiority Trial

Patients with RA on biologics or JAK inhibitors often come to orthopaedic surgery, and knowing that carefully supervised dose reduction usually preserves disease control helps in perioperative medication discussions and co-management with rheumatology.

Rigour76/100
Clinical63/100
Impact†51/100
Source band: Sound
13.SpineRCTJAMA

Initial HIV Therapy for Adults and Treatment-Associated Weight Gain

Weight gain from modern HIV regimens is a major cardiometabolic concern worldwide, and this is the first head-to-head RCT designed specifically to test whether an alternative first-line regimen can reduce that risk without sacrificing viral control.

Rigour83/100
Clinical62/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Sound
14.Shoulder & ElbowRCTJournal of Bone and Joint Surgery

Comparison of Shoulder Field Anaesthesia (SFA) with Interscalene Block (ISB) for Analgesia After Arthroscopic Shoulder Surgery

Interscalene blocks routinely paralyze the ipsilateral hemidiaphragm, so a surgeon-performed lung-sparing alternative matters for patients with poor respiratory reserve and for centres without ultrasound-guided regional anaesthesia.

Rigour91/100
Clinical62/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Sound
17.SportsRCTThe American Journal of Sports Medicine

Clinical Pathway Management for Platelet-Rich Plasma Therapy in Kellgren-Lawrence Grade I and II Knee Osteoarthritis: A Prospective, Multicentre, Double-Blind Randomised Controlled Trial

How PRP is delivered (preparation, image guidance, rehab) may matter as much as whether it is given at all, which helps explain the conflicting PRP literature in knee osteoarthritis.

Rigour90/100
Clinical57/100
Impact†50/100
Source band: Sound
18.GeneralRCTArthritis & Rheumatology

Guselkumab and structural damage in erosive psoriatic arthritis

Psoriatic arthritis can cause erosive hand and foot joint destruction that orthopaedic surgeons may later reconstruct, so knowing which biologics slow radiographic damage helps with referral and with counselling before surgery.

Rigour85/100
Clinical63/100
Impact†43/100
Source band: Sound
19.TraumaMeta-analysisJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research

Arthroscopic versus open reduction and internal fixation for tibial plateau fractures: a meta-analysis

Tibial plateau fractures are common trauma cases, and this pooled RCT evidence suggests arthroscopic-assisted fixation for lower-grade fractures may offer better function and fewer complications than the traditional open approach.

Rigour71/100
Clinical61/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Sound
21.Shoulder & ElbowRCTBritish Journal of Sports Medicine

Arthroscopic Bankart versus the open Latarjet procedure for anterior–inferior shoulder instability in young males: a randomised controlled trial with minimum 5-year follow-up

It is the only randomised comparison of the two main stabilisation operations in the highest-risk group of shoulder dislocators, and it directly informs the Bankart versus Latarjet decision often tested on boards and debated in clinic.

Rigour76/100
Clinical60/100
Impact†48/100
Source band: Sound
22.SpineCohortGlobal Spine Journal

Incidence of Tetraplegia After Cervical Laminectomy Versus Laminoplasty: A Propensity Score Matched Analysis Using US Collaborative Network Database in TriNetX

Tetraplegia after posterior cervical decompression is a rare but catastrophic complication, and these real-world incidence estimates and procedure comparisons can inform how surgeons counsel patients when choosing between laminectomy and laminoplasty.

Rigour44/100
Clinical72/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Sound
23.SportsMeta-analysisArthroscopy Sports Medicine and Rehabilitation

Double‐Bundle Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Provides Superior Short‐to‐Midterm Rotational Stability But Not Clinically Important Functional Gains Over Single‐Bundle: A Systematic Review and Meta‐analysis

Double- versus single-bundle ACL reconstruction is a classic sports medicine debate, and this review suggests any rotational stability advantage is modest, early, and does not clearly translate into function, return to sport, or graft survival.

Rigour88/100
Clinical57/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Sound
24.ArthroplastyRCTJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research

Can protein and exercise improve early recovery after hip arthroplasty?

Prehabilitation and nutritional optimisation before joint replacement are common enhanced-recovery topics, and this trial suggests a cheap, simple protein-plus-exercise bundle may speed early recovery after THA.

Rigour77/100
Clinical58/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Sound
26.TraumaCohortJournal of Hand Surgery Global Online

The Impact of Opioid-Related Disorder on Healthcare Resource Utilisation Following Distal Radius Fracture Repair Surgery

Distal radius fracture is one of the most common orthopaedic procedures, so identifying patients with opioid-related disorder as a high-utilisation, high-risk subgroup could help hand surgeons target perioperative counselling and opioid stewardship.

Rigour46/100
Clinical67/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Sound
27.SpineOtherBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders

Factors associated with 1-year health-related quality of life after neck-specific exercise in chronic whiplash-associated disorders: an exploratory secondary analysis of a randomised controlled trial

Psychological distress and baseline disability may not prevent patients with chronic whiplash from benefiting from exercise, which matters when deciding who to refer for neck-specific rehabilitation.

Rigour71/100
Clinical57/100
Impact†48/100
Source band: Sound
30.ArthroplastyMeta-analysisJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research

Psychologically informed physical therapy interventions for lower extremity surgical injuries: a systematic review and meta-analysis of clinical and self-reported outcomes

Fear of movement and catastrophizing predict poor recovery after TKA and ACL reconstruction, so knowing whether psychologically informed rehab actually helps is relevant to perioperative counselling and rehab referral.

Rigour57/100
Clinical63/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Sound
33.Foot & AnkleMeta-analysisJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research

Arthroscopic Broström repair: does the early advantage last?

Chronic lateral ankle instability is a common indication for ankle ligament surgery, and knowing that arthroscopic repair mainly changes early recovery and wound problems, not long-term function, helps frame surgical choice and patient counselling.

Rigour60/100
Clinical57/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
34.ArthroplastyRCTBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders

Minimally invasive posterior versus direct anterior hip arthroplasty

Choosing a hip arthroplasty approach is a common exam and clinic question, and this trial suggests a muscle-sparing posterior approach may bleed less and take less time than DAA in the early perioperative period. Because each approach was done by one surgeon with a different implant system, part of the difference may reflect the surgeon or implant rather than the approach itself.

Rigour64/100
Clinical59/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Sound
36.ArthroplastyRCTBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders

The effect of adding virtual reality-based rehabilitation to conventional physiotherapy on pain, function and static balance control in patients with total knee arthroplasty during the acute rehabilitation phase: a randomised controlled trial

Early rehabilitation after TKA is a high-volume, routine part of care, and low-cost motion-sensing VR is increasingly marketed as an add-on, so knowing whether it adds real benefit beyond extra therapy time is practical for counselling and resource planning.

Rigour47/100
Clinical61/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
37.ArthroplastyCohortArthroscopy The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery

Suture‐Only Fixation of Meniscal Allograft Is Associated With a Higher Reoperation Rate Than Bone Plug or Bone Bridge‐in‐Slot Fixation Techniques

For surgeons performing meniscal allograft transplantation, this study suggests that fixation technique choice may meaningfully affect long-term graft durability and reoperation risk, a key consideration in patient counselling and surgical planning.

Rigour38/100
Clinical65/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Limited
38.SpineMeta-analysisJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research

Which specific modes of exercise training are most effective for treating adolescent idiopathic scoliosis? A systematic review and network meta-analysis

Students counselling families of children with mild to moderate scoliosis should know that scoliosis-specific exercise, especially Schroth, has the strongest pooled signal for curve and rotation change, although the trials are small and often at risk of bias.

Rigour64/100
Clinical54/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
40.SpineMulticentreEuropean Spine Journal

“The protective buffer”: Adequate L4-S1 lordosis restoration reduces the symptomatic conversion of radiographic ASD and long-term revision rates — A 5-year multicentre cohort study

It suggests that getting L4-S1 lordosis into a specific numeric target at the index TLIF may be one of the biggest levers surgeons have to prevent costly, disabling revision surgery down the road.

Rigour41/100
Clinical63/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Limited
42.ArthroplastyRCTKnee Surgery Sports Traumatology Arthroscopy

Functional alignment robotic‐assisted TKA improves clinical outcomes compared with conventional mechanical alignment TKA: A single‐surgeon randomised controlled non‐inferiority trial with 2‐year follow‐up

This adds single-surgeon RCT data to the ongoing debate about whether robotic functional alignment TKA meaningfully improves patient-reported outcomes over conventional mechanically-aligned TKA, a question directly relevant to whether surgeons should adopt costly robotic platforms.

Rigour64/100
Clinical54/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
43.Hand & WristMeta-analysisHand

A Comparative Analysis of Surgical Treatment for First Carpometacarpal Osteoarthritis: A Systematic Review and Pooled Analysis of Randomised Controlled Trials

Trapeziectomy-based procedures are the classic operation for thumb CMC arthritis, and dual-mobility prostheses are a newer option that may speed early recovery, but any long-term trade-off in revision risk remains unknown.

Rigour70/100
Clinical53/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
44.Hand & WristCohortBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders

Distal radius fractures in older adults: revisiting nonoperative care

Distal radius fractures in older adults are among the most common fractures you will see, and whether to cast or plate them is a frequent exam and clinic question.

Rigour44/100
Clinical63/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
45.SpineCohortArthritis Care & Research

Osteoporotic fracture, diagnostic activity, and treatment in patients with gout

It highlights that gout patients, who are frequently exposed to glucocorticoids and have comorbid CKD, are being under-screened and undertreated for osteoporosis despite bearing a higher fracture burden, a gap relevant to any clinician managing bone health in this population.

Rigour52/100
Clinical57/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Limited
47.SpineMeta-analysisGlobal Spine Journal

Comparative Effectiveness of Intravenous, Oral, and Topical Tranexamic Acid in Elective Spine Surgery: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis

TXA is used routinely to limit bleeding in spine fusion, and this review suggests IV TXA, alone or with topical TXA, is the most reliable way to give it, while showing that safety data on thromboembolic events remain thin.

Rigour64/100
Clinical52/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
48.SpineMulticentreGlobal Spine Journal

Limited Predictive Performance of the Global Alignment and Proportion (GAP) Score for Mechanical Complications in Older Asian Patients With Adult Spinal Deformity: A Multicentre Validation Study

Spine surgeons using the GAP score to counsel older Asian patients about mechanical complication risk should know it performs poorly, essentially no better than a coin flip, in this population.

Rigour36/100
Clinical63/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Limited
49.TraumaCohortJournal of Pediatric Orthopaedics

Vitamin D Status, Supplementation and Radiographic Healing in Paediatric Both-Bone Forearm Fractures: A Prospective Controlled Study

Paediatric forearm fractures are very common, and vitamin D deficiency is a plausible modifiable factor in slower bone healing, but these results are associations from a non-randomised comparison with internal numerical inconsistencies.

Rigour41/100
Clinical59/100
Impact†53/100
Source band: Limited
50.ArthroplastyCohortJournal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons

Robotic-Assisted Total Hip Arthroplasty Is Associated With Lower Prosthetic Complications in Patients With Lumbar Fusion or Stiff Spine: A Propensity-Matched Cohort Study

This adds observational support for using robotic assistance in a high dislocation-risk THA population, a decision point residents will face increasingly often as spinopelvic considerations become standard in preoperative planning.

Rigour31/100
Clinical66/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Limited
Scores are out of 100. † Impact reflects editorial priority.
Paper selection

A critical eye. An open method.