The archive35

Every edition. An expanding view of orthopaedic evidence.

The complete collectionBrowse published appraisals
35 papers · RCT
1.GeneralRCTClinical Rehabilitation

Effects of short-term compression in people with knee osteoarthritis: A sham-controlled randomised trial

Compression bandaging and soft braces are commonly recommended or self-applied for knee osteoarthritis pain, and this trial suggests short courses of simple elastic compression have no clinically meaningful benefit over a sham wrap or no treatment, which should temper enthusiasm for this low-cost adjunct.

Rigour100/100
Clinical66/100
Impact†65/100
Source band: Strong
4.Foot & AnkleRCTBMJ

Efficacy and cost effectiveness of high volume injections with and without corticosteroid compared with sham for midportion Achilles tendinopathy (Inject trial): randomised controlled trial

High volume injections are increasingly offered for stubborn Achilles tendinopathy, and this sham-controlled trial suggests they add no lasting benefit to exercise, with steroid offering only brief relief and possible later harm.

Rigour100/100
Clinical59/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Sound
5.TraumaRCTJournal of Pediatric Orthopaedics

Casting Without Reduction Versus Reduction With or Without Fixation for Mildly Displaced Paediatric Distal Radius Metaphyseal Fractures: A Randomised Noninferiority Trial

Paediatric distal radius fractures are the most common childhood fracture, and knowing when remodelling makes reduction unnecessary can spare young children anaesthesia, pins, and their complications.

Rigour62/100
Clinical65/100
Impact†65/100
Source band: Sound
7.SportsRCTThe American Journal of Sports Medicine

A Single Intra-articular Injection of Autologous Stromal Vascular Fraction for Moderate-to-Severe Knee Osteoarthritis: Results of a Multicentre Randomised Placebo-Controlled Trial With 12-Month Follow-up

Cell-based injections for knee arthritis are widely marketed, so a sham-controlled trial showing a 12-month responder benefit (with a wide confidence interval and an unusual composite endpoint) is directly relevant to how you counsel patients asking about biologics.

Rigour86/100
Clinical62/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Sound
8.GeneralRCTArthritis & Rheumatology

Outcomes of Tapering Biologic and Targeted Synthetic DMARDs in Rheumatoid Arthritis: A Multicentre Randomised Non‐Inferiority Trial

Patients with RA on biologics or JAK inhibitors often come to orthopaedic surgery, and knowing that carefully supervised dose reduction usually preserves disease control helps in perioperative medication discussions and co-management with rheumatology.

Rigour76/100
Clinical63/100
Impact†51/100
Source band: Sound
9.SpineRCTJAMA

Initial HIV Therapy for Adults and Treatment-Associated Weight Gain

Weight gain from modern HIV regimens is a major cardiometabolic concern worldwide, and this is the first head-to-head RCT designed specifically to test whether an alternative first-line regimen can reduce that risk without sacrificing viral control.

Rigour83/100
Clinical62/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Sound
10.Shoulder & ElbowRCTJournal of Bone and Joint Surgery

Comparison of Shoulder Field Anaesthesia (SFA) with Interscalene Block (ISB) for Analgesia After Arthroscopic Shoulder Surgery

Interscalene blocks routinely paralyze the ipsilateral hemidiaphragm, so a surgeon-performed lung-sparing alternative matters for patients with poor respiratory reserve and for centres without ultrasound-guided regional anaesthesia.

Rigour91/100
Clinical62/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Sound
11.SportsRCTThe American Journal of Sports Medicine

Clinical Pathway Management for Platelet-Rich Plasma Therapy in Kellgren-Lawrence Grade I and II Knee Osteoarthritis: A Prospective, Multicentre, Double-Blind Randomised Controlled Trial

How PRP is delivered (preparation, image guidance, rehab) may matter as much as whether it is given at all, which helps explain the conflicting PRP literature in knee osteoarthritis.

Rigour90/100
Clinical57/100
Impact†50/100
Source band: Sound
12.GeneralRCTArthritis & Rheumatology

Guselkumab and structural damage in erosive psoriatic arthritis

Psoriatic arthritis can cause erosive hand and foot joint destruction that orthopaedic surgeons may later reconstruct, so knowing which biologics slow radiographic damage helps with referral and with counselling before surgery.

Rigour85/100
Clinical63/100
Impact†43/100
Source band: Sound
13.Shoulder & ElbowRCTBritish Journal of Sports Medicine

Arthroscopic Bankart versus the open Latarjet procedure for anterior–inferior shoulder instability in young males: a randomised controlled trial with minimum 5-year follow-up

It is the only randomised comparison of the two main stabilisation operations in the highest-risk group of shoulder dislocators, and it directly informs the Bankart versus Latarjet decision often tested on boards and debated in clinic.

Rigour76/100
Clinical60/100
Impact†48/100
Source band: Sound
14.ArthroplastyRCTJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research

Can protein and exercise improve early recovery after hip arthroplasty?

Prehabilitation and nutritional optimisation before joint replacement are common enhanced-recovery topics, and this trial suggests a cheap, simple protein-plus-exercise bundle may speed early recovery after THA.

Rigour77/100
Clinical58/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Sound
17.ArthroplastyRCTBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders

Minimally invasive posterior versus direct anterior hip arthroplasty

Choosing a hip arthroplasty approach is a common exam and clinic question, and this trial suggests a muscle-sparing posterior approach may bleed less and take less time than DAA in the early perioperative period. Because each approach was done by one surgeon with a different implant system, part of the difference may reflect the surgeon or implant rather than the approach itself.

Rigour64/100
Clinical59/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Sound
18.ArthroplastyRCTBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders

The effect of adding virtual reality-based rehabilitation to conventional physiotherapy on pain, function and static balance control in patients with total knee arthroplasty during the acute rehabilitation phase: a randomised controlled trial

Early rehabilitation after TKA is a high-volume, routine part of care, and low-cost motion-sensing VR is increasingly marketed as an add-on, so knowing whether it adds real benefit beyond extra therapy time is practical for counselling and resource planning.

Rigour47/100
Clinical61/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
19.ArthroplastyRCTKnee Surgery Sports Traumatology Arthroscopy

Functional alignment robotic‐assisted TKA improves clinical outcomes compared with conventional mechanical alignment TKA: A single‐surgeon randomised controlled non‐inferiority trial with 2‐year follow‐up

This adds single-surgeon RCT data to the ongoing debate about whether robotic functional alignment TKA meaningfully improves patient-reported outcomes over conventional mechanically-aligned TKA, a question directly relevant to whether surgeons should adopt costly robotic platforms.

Rigour64/100
Clinical54/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
20.SpineRCTBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders

The effect of functional inspiratory muscle training on diaphragm function and core stabilisation in patients with chronic non-specific low back pain: a randomised controlled trial

Chronic low back pain is one of the most common musculoskeletal complaints, and this trial shows how a supervised, exercise-heavy rehabilitation package can outperform minimal home breathing exercises, although this does not prove that the diaphragm-training component itself is the key ingredient.

Rigour56/100
Clinical54/100
Impact†48/100
Source band: Limited
21.SportsRCTBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders

A randomised controlled trial of brachial plexus block manipulation versus steroid injection in conscious patients for moderate to severe shoulder stiffness

Frozen shoulder is extremely common and often slow to resolve with steroid injection alone, so a same-day, ultrasound-guided manipulation protocol that avoids general anaesthesia could change how orthopaedic surgeons manage refractory stiffness in the clinic.

Rigour61/100
Clinical51/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Limited
22.ArthroplastyRCTBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders

Bedside pedalling after knee replacement: a small addition to early rehabilitation

Early mobilisation after knee replacement is standard, and this trial suggests that a cheap bedside cycle may add short-term gains in pain, motion and function, which is relevant when counselling patients on inpatient rehab after TKR.

Rigour65/100
Clinical51/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Limited
24.Foot & AnkleRCTJournal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology

Pulsed electromagnetic fields (PEMFs) in complex regional pain syndrome type I (CRPS-I) of the foot: a randomised controlled trial

CRPS-I of the foot/ankle is a difficult, disabling condition with limited proven adjuncts, so evidence about a home-use, non-invasive PEMF device is relevant to orthopaedic and rehabilitation practice even though this trial is small and unblinded.

Rigour62/100
Clinical47/100
Impact†49/100
Source band: Limited
28.PaediatricsRCTJournal of Pediatric Orthopaedics

Lateral Opening-Wedge Versus Medial Closing-Wedge Distal Femoral Osteotomy for Adolescent Idiopathic Genu Valgum: A Randomised Controlled Trial

Once the physis has closed, guided growth is no longer an option for adolescent genu valgum, so knowing that both osteotomy types correct alignment well but change leg length in opposite directions helps with technique choice and family counselling.

Rigour69/100
Clinical42/100
Impact†48/100
Source band: Limited
30.SportsRCTKnee Surgery Sports Traumatology Arthroscopy

Short‐term benefits of hybrid graft in medial patellofemoral ligament reconstruction for recurrent patellar dislocation: A prospective randomised controlled trial with minimum 2‐year follow‐up

Graft choice in MPFL reconstruction is a common patellofemoral instability question, and this trial suggests synthetic augmentation may speed early recovery without changing 1-year function, while long-term safety of synthetic material remains unknown.

Rigour55/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Limited
31.Shoulder & ElbowRCTShoulder & Elbow

Restoring the anatomic tension relationship of the long head of the biceps during tenodesis: A prospective, randomised controlled trial

Biceps tenodesis is common and lacks a standardised tensioning technique, so evidence on whether a more meticulous patient-specific method actually improves outcomes helps surgeons decide if the extra technical effort is worthwhile.

Rigour40/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Limited
32.SpineRCTSpine

Effect of Intrawound Vancomycin Powder on the Pathogen Spectrum and Antimicrobial Susceptibility of Postoperative Infections in Elective Lumbar Fusion

Many spine surgeons already use intrawound vancomycin powder for SSI prophylaxis, and this trial addresses a lingering safety worry from retrospective data that it might shift infections toward resistant or gram-negative organisms.

Rigour40/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Limited
33.SpineRCTJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research

Effects of dynamic neuromuscular stabilization with and without immersive virtual reality on pain, postural, and functional outcomes in women with lumbar hyperlordosis and chronic non-specific low back pain: a randomised controlled trial

Core motor-control exercise programmes are a mainstay for chronic non-specific low back pain, and this trial tests whether a consumer VR headset adds measurable value on top of them.

Rigour55/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†45/100
Source band: Limited
34.GeneralRCTJAMA Network Open

Restrictive vs Liberal Transfusion Strategy After Myocardial Infarction

Anemic MI patients are common in both cardiology and perioperative orthopaedic settings, and this reanalysis illustrates how a 'negative' P=.07 trial can be reframed as supportive evidence using Bayesian statistics, a distinction trainees should recognise when reading transfusion literature.

Rigour40/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†—/100
Source band: Limited
35.Foot & AnkleRCTFoot & Ankle International

To Walk or Not? A Prospective, Randomised Controlled Trial to Evaluate the Effect of Weightbearing on Patient Outcomes Following First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Fusion

First MTP fusion is the standard operation for end-stage hallux rigidus, and whether patients must stay off the foot for 6 weeks has a large effect on driving, work, falls risk and who can safely be offered surgery.

Rigour40/100
Clinical45/100
Impact†48/100
Source band: Limited
Scores are out of 100. † Impact reflects editorial priority.
Paper selection

A critical eye. An open method.